|
Citation
|
Judgment date
|
| June 2024 |
|
|
Permanent employment inferred from ambiguous confirmation; dismissal unlawful for failure to notify and permit representation, remedies awarded.
Employment law – contract ambiguity and confirmation letters – open-ended/permanent versus fixed-term contracts; Procedural fairness – s66 and s68 Employment Act – right to be notified and heard before dismissal; Remedies – severance, general damages, repatriation, interest; Special damages and punitive damages denied for lack of proof.
|
27 June 2024 |
|
Permanent employment confirmed by omission of fixed term; dismissal without notice or opportunity to be heard was unlawful.
Employment law — probation and confirmation — omission of contract duration — ambiguity resolved in favour of employee; dismissal — statutory requirement to notify and permit response before termination; employer’s burden to prove justification — remedies for unlawful termination: severance, general damages, repatriation; dismissal without proof is unfair.
|
27 June 2024 |
|
Claimant lawfully dismissed for 51‑day absence; only unremitted NSSF contributions ordered remitted.
Employment law – dismissal for abscondment – procedural and substantive fairness of disciplinary hearings; constructive dismissal – requirements and proof; remedies – salary arrears, terminal benefits and NSSF remittance (order to remit UGX 2,515,464).
|
26 June 2024 |
|
Unlawful summary dismissal for lack of notification and hearing; claimant awarded general and aggravated damages, interest and costs.
Employment law – unfair dismissal – procedural fairness under Section 66 Employment Act 2006 – requirement of notification and hearing; substantive fairness – employer’s burden to prove allegations; claims for salary/NSSF require documentary proof; compensation for unexpired fixed‑term contract speculative; awards of general and aggravated damages; interest and costs.
|
26 June 2024 |
|
Whether a resigning employee is entitled to full terminal benefits absent a qualified medical retirement recommendation.
Labour law – Resignation versus medical retirement – Interpretation of staff handbook (BHR) provisions – Requirement of medical recommendation for medical retirement – Entitlement to unpaid wages, accrued leave, statutory severance under Section 87EA, certificate of service and costs.
|
25 June 2024 |
|
An employment dispute governed by a cooperative’s arbitration clause must be referred to arbitration; the Industrial Court lacked jurisdiction.
Industrial/Employment law – jurisdiction – arbitration agreement in cooperative byelaws; Cooperative Societies Act s.73 – definition of "officer" includes employees; LADASA s.6 – Labour Officer must refer disputes to agreed arbitration; Arbitration and Conciliation Act s.5(1) – court to refer proceedings to arbitration unless agreement void or no dispute.
|
25 June 2024 |
|
A cooperative employee's dispute covered by the society's arbitration clause must be referred to arbitration; Industrial Court lacked jurisdiction.
Cooperative Societies Act (s73) – disputes touching business of a registered society – mandatory referral to arbitration; definition of "officer" includes employees. Bye-laws (clause 55) – arbitration clause requiring unresolved disputes to be referred to arbitrator(s). Labour Disputes (Arbitration and Settlement) Act (s6) – Labour Officer to ensure parties follow conciliation/arbitration arrangements; not to refer to Industrial Court. Arbitration and Conciliation Act (s5(1)) – duty of judge to refer proceedings back to arbitration where an arbitration agreement applies. Civil procedure – Order 9 r3 procedural objection considered but substance and jurisdiction decided in interest of justice. Jurisdiction – court lacks jurisdiction where matter is subject to a valid arbitration agreement.
|
25 June 2024 |
|
Leave to appeal granted only for factual findings forming part of the Labour Officer's decision; preliminary matters excluded.
Employment law – Appeal from Labour Officer – Section 94(2) Employment Act 2006 – Leave required to appeal questions of fact or mixed law and fact. Civil procedure – Distinction between questions of law and questions of fact; appellate interference limited to errors of law or misapplication of legal principle. Labour arbitration – What constitutes part of the Labour Officer's decision for purposes of leave to appeal; preliminary matters excluded, evaluation of evidence included.
|
21 June 2024 |
|
Industrial Court may admit the respondent’s late-filed documents and assess their weight; Section 30 not established.
Labour procedure – Admissibility of late-filed documentary evidence – Industrial Court not bound by strict civil evidence rules (Section 18 Labour Disputes Act) – Late disclosure may prejudice but does not automatically justify expungement – Documents admitted for identification and assessed for weight – Insufficient basis to invoke Section 30 Evidence Act.
|
5 June 2024 |
| May 2024 |
|
|
Counsel's bereavement and the applicant's serious illness amounted to sufficient cause to set aside a dismissal for non-appearance.
Civil procedure – Order 9 Rule 22 CPR – Reinstatement of suit dismissed for non‑appearance; 'sufficient cause' includes advocate's bereavement and party's serious illness; requirement to fix matter for hearing once dismissal set aside.
|
31 May 2024 |
|
An appeal filed beyond the statutory 30‑day period without leave is incompetent and is dismissed.
Labour law – appeals – computation of time – Regulation 45(1) Employment Regulations (30 days) – exclude date of decision and count thirty clear days. Civil procedure – Order 51 r.2 CPR – exclusion of Sundays/public holidays applies only to time periods less than six days. Interpretation Act s.34 – rules for computing time (exclude first day; extend if last day falls on excluded day). Procedural competence – appeal filed out of time without leave is incompetent. Costs – pro se litigant entitled to disbursements, not costs.
|
24 May 2024 |
|
Court ordered independent forensic examination to determine recoverability of a deleted internal email relevant to whistleblowing and dismissal.
Discovery – relevance, possession and control – deleted or deactivated electronic mail – admissible evidence Digital forensics – recoverability of erased emails – expert evidence vs. IT assertions Labour law – application of section 8(2a) LADASA (as amended) to compel inspection and expert assistance Procedural fairness – balancing data privacy with the need to ascertain truth and prevent surprise
|
24 May 2024 |
|
An injunction application to prevent sale of property was dismissed for lis pendens and being a duplicative, abusive proceeding; costs awarded.
Civil procedure – Lis pendens – Section 6 Civil Procedure Act – earlier subsisting injunction between same parties and over same property bars proceeding.* Temporary injunction – duplicative applications – abuse of court process where applicant seeks to injunct property already under court order.* Costs – partial costs awarded where defending party not put to strenuous defence.
|
20 May 2024 |
|
Industrial Court has statutory jurisdiction to hear employer counterclaims arising from employment disputes; jurisdiction may be challenged in defence.
Industrial Court – jurisdiction – statutory foundation under LADASA – referral and appellate jurisdiction; concurrent jurisdiction with High Court. Labour law – employer counterclaims – employer may sue in Industrial Court for losses arising from employee’s breach of trust or contract. Civil procedure – jurisdictional objections – party who files claim/defence may still challenge substantive jurisdiction as a preliminary point.
|
17 May 2024 |
|
Fixed-term contract was constructively renewed, but unpaid salary and other unpleaded remedies were not proved and claim dismissed.
Employment law – fixed-term contract – constructive renewal by conduct where employer accepts work and pays after expiry; proof of unpaid wages requires specific pleading and evidence; parties bound by pleadings; casual employment distinguished from monthly payments; terminal benefits and other remedies must be pleaded and supported by contract or statute.
|
17 May 2024 |
|
Non-renewal before the operative fixed-term expiry amounted to unlawful termination; claimant awarded notice, salary, leave and damages.
Labour law – fixed-term contract – contractual commencement and expiry – non-renewal as termination – premature unilateral termination unlawful; remedies: payment in lieu of notice, unpaid salary, untaken leave and general damages; salary loan recognized and offset against awards; no costs.
|
17 May 2024 |
|
Claimant lawfully summarily dismissed for unauthorised absence; awarded three months’ pay in lieu and service fee only.
Employment law – summary dismissal for unauthorised absence/insubordination – disciplinary suspension (section 62) v investigative suspension (section 63) – entitlement to gratuity, repatriation and damages; award of pay in lieu and service fee only.
|
17 May 2024 |
|
Section 164 IA does not bar claims to contributions held by the NSSF because those sums are not debts of the employer.
Insolvency Act s.164 – effect of administration deed – scope: applies to creditors with provable, quantifiable claims predating deed; statutory pension/social security contributions held by NSSF are not employer debts and do not make employees creditors of employer – Industrial Court has jurisdiction to determine entitlement to funds held by NSSF without leave under s.164.
|
15 May 2024 |
|
Dismissal substantively justified but procedurally unfair: unlawful suspension and failure to disclose investigation report; limited statutory remedies awarded.
Labour law – dismissal for misconduct – substantive justification v procedural fairness; unlawful suspension exceeding statutory limit; duty to disclose investigation report before disciplinary hearing; internal appeals and double jeopardy; remedies limited where dismissal substantively justified but procedurally flawed.
|
7 May 2024 |
| April 2024 |
|
|
Whether the claimant was an employee entitled to unpaid wages and what remedies and quantum are appropriate.
Labour law – employment status – employee v independent contractor; proof of wages – contemporaneous pay receipts and parol evidence rule; quantum meruit – limits where a fixed sum is alleged; constructive dismissal and compensatory orders; awards of interest and costs in labour disputes.
|
19 April 2024 |
|
Industrial Court has referral jurisdiction under Section 24 LUA; applicant must file a formal reference for contested recognition dispute.
Labour law – recognition of trade unions – procedure under Section 24 Labour Unions Act; Industrial Court jurisdiction – referral and appellate (not unlimited original) jurisdiction; requirement to use formal reference procedure for contested factual/legal issues; Tripartite Charter – validity/effect not determined on motion where Registrar procedures and evidence are absent.
|
12 April 2024 |
|
Worker labelled contractor held to be an employee and unlawfully summarily dismissed; awarded severance and damages.
Employment law – employee v independent contractor – control, integration and economic reality (multiple-test) – summary dismissal without hearing – statutory dismissal procedure (sections 66, 68, 69 Employment Act) – remedies: severance and general damages.
|
12 April 2024 |
|
Termination for alleged restructuring was procedurally and substantively unlawful; employee entitled to reimbursement, severance and damages.
Employment law – unfair termination – restructuring/redundancy – procedural requirements for collective terminations (s.81 Employment Act) – proof of reason for termination (s.68) – unlawful deductions from wages – remedies: declaration, notice pay, severance, reimbursement and general damages.
|
12 April 2024 |
|
Oral employment contract found; dismissal unlawful for failure to accord fair hearing and prove misconduct.
Employment law – existence and nature of contract (oral v. written probationary contract); unfair dismissal – employer's burden to prove reason and comply with right to be heard (Sections 66, 68 Employment Act); evidentiary rules – expungement of witness statement where witness fails to attend; remedies – salary arrears, payment in lieu of notice, prorated severance, statutory compensation under s.66(4), general damages; costs/disbursements for unrepresented claimant.
|
5 April 2024 |
|
Application to disqualify opposing counsel dismissed for lack of evidence that advocates are witnesses or conflicted.
Advocates – disqualification – Regulation 9 Advocates (Professional Conduct) Regulations – when an advocate is a witness and disqualification is required. Advocate–client privilege – protection of communications for legal advice and narrow exceptions (fraud/crime). Right to choose counsel – limits on interfering with a party’s selection of legal representation. Conflict of interest – requirement to show compellable testimony or demonstrable prejudice before restraining counsel.
|
2 April 2024 |
| March 2024 |
|
|
Application to vacate consent injunction dismissed; press release admitted unremitted sum but not sufficient for judgment; matter fast-tracked.
Consent injunctions – variation or vacatur – limited grounds (fraud, mistake, misapprehension, illegality); status quo and risk of rendering main suit nugatory. Admissions – newspaper/press release admissible; clear admission of audited unremitted NSSF sum but not dispositive where entitlement and excepted employment disputed. Costs in employment disputes – interlocutory costs not awarded; costs generally follow the event but Court discretion applies. Case management – direction to fast-track and finally determine outstanding entitlement issues.
|
28 March 2024 |
|
Claimant failed to prove salary arrears; respondent must continue paying pension of UGX 240,000 monthly.
Labour law – clergy remuneration – absence of uniform salary structure; burden of proof on claimant to prove contractual terms and arrears; parish‑based stipends versus diocesan payments; sufficiency of late retrospective letters as proof; entitlement to pension continues post‑retirement.
|
25 March 2024 |
|
Application to amend pleadings to substitute compensation remedies was dismissed as statute-barred with no exemption pleaded.
Labour law — amendment of pleadings — leave to amend — substitution of remedies — limitation of actions — six-year limitation for employment disputes — statute-barred claims — no pleaded grounds for extension/exemption.
|
15 March 2024 |
|
Substantively justified dismissal for password-sharing was procedurally flawed due to insufficient notice, rendering the dismissal unlawful.
Employment law – dismissal – procedural fairness: employer must give reasonable time to prepare and disclose relevant investigation material; failure to follow higher internal disciplinary standards is a procedural irregularity. Employment law – dismissal – substantive fairness: admission (oral or in appeal) and video evidence can justify dismissal for password-sharing in banking sector. Remedies – procedural breach attracts statutory compensation (four weeks' net pay) and possible general damages; punitive damages exceptional.
|
15 March 2024 |
|
Summary redundancy without proper consultation or statutory notice is unlawful and attracts compensation.
Employment law – redundancy – procedural and substantive fairness – sufficient notice and consultation required; denial of fair hearing; jurisdiction of the Industrial Court over torts ancillary to employment; whistleblower protection limited to public-interest disclosures; negligent/malicious reference and privacy claims require specific proof; remedies include statutory compensation, general and aggravated damages, interest and certificate of service.
|
11 March 2024 |
|
Prolonged suspension beyond statutory period amounted to unlawful suspension and constructive dismissal; remedies awarded.
Employment law – Suspension – Section 63 EA – suspension limited to four weeks or duration of inquiry; prolonged suspension unlawful. Employment law – Constructive dismissal – Section 65(1)(c) EA – indefinite unresolved suspension may amount to fundamental breach and constructive dismissal. Remedies – payment in lieu of notice (Section 58), severance (Section 87), half-pay for lawful suspension, general damages, interest and costs.
|
1 March 2024 |
|
Labour Officer improperly converted conciliation into adjudication; award set aside and matter remitted for fresh hearing.
Labour law — dispute resolution — conciliation vs adjudication — Labour Officer's discretion under s.13 Employment Act — procedural fairness and right to a fair hearing — constructive dismissal award set aside and matter remitted for fresh determination.
|
1 March 2024 |
| February 2024 |
|
|
Lis pendens bars a second application for identical interim relief pending between the same parties in another court.
Industrial Court – Interim injunction – Res judicata inapplicable to interlocutory orders; Lis pendens (Section 6 CPA) bars subsequent proceedings between same parties over same subject matter and relief pending in another competent court; Non‑compliance with earlier court order and multiplicity of suits may attract costs for abuse of process.
|
2 February 2024 |
| January 2024 |
|
|
An application to set aside a non-existent ex parte order fails, but the applicant is allowed to file pre-trial documents with costs awarded to the respondent.
Civil procedure – setting aside ex parte proceedings – no extant ex parte order means nothing to set aside under Order 9 Rule 21 CPR; Industrial Court discretion – equity and Rule 6 permit extension to file pre-trial documents; employment disputes – costs exceptional but awardable where party at fault for procedural non-compliance.
|
30 January 2024 |
|
Applicant entitled to respondent's 2015–2022 sales and accounting records to prove unpaid commission.
Discovery/Inspection — Order 10 Rule 18 CPR; threshold: possession, power or control of documents; relevance to pending suit; liberal prima facie standard for disclosure; prohibition of fishing expeditions; retention periods and reasonableness of ordering six years (2015–2022) of sales and audited accounts.
|
30 January 2024 |
|
Interim stay of execution granted; notice of appeal held timely; propriety of appeal for Court of Appeal; deponent’s authority sufficient.
Civil procedure – interim stay of execution – Order 50 CPR – requirement of pending substantive application with likelihood of success and preservation of status quo. Appeals – computation of time – exclusion of Christmas vacation (24 Dec–15 Jan) in reckoning appeal period. Appeals – propriety/competence of grounds of appeal – matters for Court of Appeal under COA Rules, not Industrial Court. Procedure – authority of advocates and deponents – power of attorney not always required for affidavits; law firm name change explained.
|
29 January 2024 |
|
Court granted a Section 19 certificate certifying UGX 78,380,915 payable by the Government; no costs ordered.
Government Proceedings Act, s.19 – certification of satisfaction of orders against the Government; requirements of 21-day period and taxation of costs; Registrar’s role under Government Proceedings (Civil Procedure) Rules r.14; issuance of Form A certificate; unopposed application and costs.
|
25 January 2024 |