|
Citation
|
Judgment date
|
| December 2023 |
|
|
Employer failed to follow mandatory disciplinary procedure; dismissal held substantively and procedurally unlawful, statutory remedies awarded.
Employment law – unfair and unlawful dismissal – failure to comply with Sections 66 and 68 (notification, hearing, proof of reason) – insufficiency of gate-recorded admission – remedies: notice in lieu, severance, suspension pay, general damages – punitive damages denied.
|
21 December 2023 |
|
Application for reinstatement of a dismissed labor dispute denied due to inadequate cause demonstrated by applicants.
Labour Law – reinstatement of dismissed dispute – sufficient cause – non-compliance with court directives – illness of agent.
|
21 December 2023 |
|
|
18 December 2023 |
|
|
14 December 2023 |
|
Employee unlawfully dismissed for enforcing employer’s COVID‑19 mask directive; awarded notice, severance and damages.
Employment law – unfair dismissal – enforcement of employer COVID‑19 workplace directive – procedural fairness in disciplinary process – remedies: pay in lieu, prorated wages, severance (one month per year), general damages – untaken leave requires proof of denied leave application – interest and costs.
|
11 December 2023 |
| November 2023 |
|
|
Failure to reply was treated as no objection; leave to amend claims (clarifying facts and correcting computations) was granted with taxed costs.
• Civil procedure – Amendment of pleadings – Order 6 Rules 19 & 31 CPR – Amendments to amplify facts and correct computations allowed where no new cause of action or prejudice arises. • Failure to file reply – treated as acceptance of averments/no objection. • Labour law procedure – costs exceptional but may be awarded for misconduct/non-compliance with directions.
|
30 November 2023 |
|
Summary dismissals without prior notice, investigation or proof of admission are unlawful; damages and severance awarded.
Employment law – summary dismissal – requirement of substantive and procedural fairness (Sections 58, 65, 66, 68, 69, 70(6) Employment Act) – employer’s burden to prove admission – remedies: declaration, general damages, severance, interest – unproven NSSF claim denied.
|
30 November 2023 |
|
A Labour Officer may extend filing time beyond three months but not beyond the six‑year Limitation Act period; unpleaded disability fails.
Limitation law – interaction of s.71(2) Employment Act and s.3(1) Limitation Act – Labour Officer may extend three‑month filing period but not beyond six‑year statutory limitation; requirement to plead disability/exemption in plaint (Order 7 Rule 6 CPR); late/unpleaded disability allegations insufficient to defeat limitation defence.
|
28 November 2023 |
|
Extension of time granted for appeal where notice was mislaid; leave granted to appeal mixed questions of law and fact.
* Civil procedure – extension of time – sufficient cause – mistake of counsel and mislaid notice may constitute sufficient cause to extend time. * Labour law – appeals from Labour Officer to Industrial Court – a notice of appeal under the Seventeenth Schedule suffices to commence appeal without awaiting certified proceedings. * Leave to appeal – threshold for questions of law and leave for questions of fact – leave granted for mixed law and fact where arguable issues exist. * Procedure – affidavits filed outside court directions may be struck out; falsehoods subject to severance only if established.
|
20 November 2023 |
|
Voluntary resignation found; claimant awarded unpaid wages, accrued leave and general damages, not constructive dismissal.
Employment law – constructive dismissal – resignation – when resignation amounts to constructive dismissal; statutory leave and unpaid wages – proof and computation; special damages – requirement of specific pleading and strict proof; general damages and interest.
|
17 November 2023 |
|
Fixed‑term contract with a probationary period does not negate the statutory right to a hearing before dismissal.
Labour law – fixed‑term contract with probationary period vs probationary contract – right to fair hearing (Secs 66 and 67 Employment Act) – admissibility before Labour Officer – remedies for unlawful dismissal (compensation, severance, public holiday and leave pay, general damages) – interest and costs.
|
13 November 2023 |
|
A fixed‑term contract with a probationary period does not extinguish the employee's right to a fair hearing before dismissal.
* Employment law – fixed‑term contract containing probationary clause – distinction between probationary contract and fixed‑term contract with probationary period.
* Labour procedure – Labour Officer not a court of record – wide procedural discretion; Evidence Act judicial notice rules not binding.
* Right to fair hearing – Section 66EA mandatory; Section 67EA cannot be construed to derogate constitutional right to fair hearing.
* Remedies – statutory compensation for failure to hold hearing, public holiday pay shortfall, severance pay, general damages and interest.
|
13 November 2023 |
|
Counsel’s mistake in awaiting a medical report amounted to sufficient cause to extend time and validate the dispute reference.
* Civil procedure – LADASA Rule 6(1) and Section 98 CPA – extension of time to file documents – requirement of sufficient cause; * Procedural fairness – solicitor’s/Counsel’s mistake or omission can constitute sufficient cause; * Industrial Court jurisdiction – unfair termination claims fall within court’s competence.
|
10 November 2023 |
|
Industrial Court cannot extend time or validate appeals to the Court of Appeal; such power lies with the appellate court, so stay denied.
* Procedural law – jurisdiction – power to extend time for appeal – extension of time and validation of notices of appeal vested in appellate court under CPA and Court of Appeal Rules. * Civil procedure – stay of execution – stay requires a properly lodged and served appeal to preserve status quo. * Solicitor negligence – negligence of former counsel does not confer jurisdiction on trial court to extend time for appeals governed by appellate rules.
|
10 November 2023 |
|
The Industrial Court lacks jurisdiction over the respondent's workers' compensation claim; that portion must be severed.
Labour law; jurisdiction—Industrial Court lacks original jurisdiction over Workers' Compensation Act claims; Magistrates' Courts have statutory jurisdiction; severance of causes of action; timeliness validated by prior extension.
|
10 November 2023 |
|
Industrial Court lacks jurisdiction over Workers Compensation claims; such claims must be severed and heard by magistrates' courts.
Industrial Court — jurisdiction — Workers Compensation Act — magistrates' court has original jurisdiction over WCA claims; Industrial Court has referral/appellate jurisdiction only; severance of non‑jurisdictional causes of action; unfair termination claim to proceed.
|
10 November 2023 |
|
Court extended time to file claim, holding counsel's mistake can constitute sufficient cause; dispute validated; no costs.
Labour procedure – enlargement of time to file pleadings; Rule 6(1) LADASA – discretionary extension; sufficient cause – mistake or omission by counsel can constitute sufficient cause; Industrial Court jurisdiction – unfair termination claims distinguished from workers' compensation matters.
|
10 November 2023 |
|
Court stayed damages reference pending appeal, extended time to file appeal grounds due to delayed lower record.
Employment law – Labour Officer’s limited jurisdiction to award statutory remedies – referral of non‑statutory damages to Industrial Court; Industrial Court procedure – commencement of appeal under Regulation 45 ER requires a notice of appeal listing grounds (Seventeenth Schedule); duty of Registrar/Labour Officer to furnish lower record; discretion to extend time where record delay not fault of appellant; stay of reference under section 6 CPA to avoid conflicting decisions.
|
2 November 2023 |
| October 2023 |
|
|
Mutual separation was lawful; release clauses cannot bar statutory labour remedies, claimant's further claims unproven.
Employment law – termination by mutual agreement – consent and free will; Separation Agreement – duress and coercion; Release/exclusion clauses – void if they preclude statutory labour rights (Employment Act) or access to labour officers/courts; Estoppel/approbation and reprobation – effect of signing separation deed; Remedies – future salary speculative; proof required for special/aggravated damages.
|
27 October 2023 |
|
The claimant was constructively dismissed when the respondent removed his office and replaced him, warranting compensation.
Employment law – Constructive dismissal – Unreasonable conduct by employer under s65(1)(c) Employment Act 2006; Procedure for termination – ss65,66,68,69,70(6); Collective/collective-termination notification obligations under s81; Remedies for unfair termination – severance (one month per year), notice in lieu, salary arrears, general damages; Burden of proof where claimant’s evidence is unchallenged.
|
27 October 2023 |
|
A labour complaint filed over six years after dismissal is time-barred; statutory exceptions must be pleaded to extend limitation.
Labour law – limitation of actions – six-year limitation under Limitation Act – Labour Officer’s discretion under Section 71(2) of the Employment Act constrained by Limitation Act – statutory exemptions (disability, acknowledgment, part payment, fraud, mistake) required to extend time – illegality of dismissal not sufficient without pleaded statutory exception.
|
25 October 2023 |
|
|
24 October 2023 |
|
Summary dismissal without a formal disciplinary hearing was procedurally and substantively unfair; claimant awarded compensation and damages.
Employment law – unfair dismissal – procedural fairness – requirement for written notice and formal disciplinary hearing under Section 66 EA; Substantive fairness – employer must prove gross/fundamental misconduct to justify summary dismissal; Informal meetings and unrecorded admissions do not satisfy statutory hearing requirements; Remedies – statutory compensation, payment in lieu of notice, general damages, certificate of service; salary arrears, NSSF, repatriation claims require specific proof.
|
23 October 2023 |
|
Withholding an investigation report and failing to record an appeal rendered the dismissal procedurally and substantively unfair.
Employment law – Unfair summary dismissal – procedural fairness requires disclosure of investigation report in whistleblower cases – failure to furnish report and to record appeal outcome vitiates hearing – employer must prove genuine belief under s.68 EA – remedies: declaration, certificate of service, severance, payment in lieu, four weeks' pay for hearing breach, general damages, interest.
|
13 October 2023 |
|
Application to amend pleadings to add a fraud counterclaim was dismissed as dilatory, prejudicial and changing the cause of action.
Civil procedure – amendment of pleadings – principles governing amendments (not mala fide; not introduce distinct cause of action; not cause uncompensable prejudice; limitation) – labour law – Industrial Court’s jurisdiction and trial by ambush.
|
13 October 2023 |
|
|
10 October 2023 |
|
Claimants’ dismissal held unfair for failure to provide investigation report and to prove alleged bribery.
Employment law – unfair dismissal – Sections 66 and 68 Employment Act 2006 – employer’s duty to disclose investigation report and prove reasons for dismissal on balance of probabilities; remedies – severance pay (one month’s salary per year of service), general damages; interest on pecuniary awards; unsuccessful claims for fines, service awards, loan recovery and future earnings.
|
10 October 2023 |
|
Industrial Court may apply CPR to witness statements; late rebuttal-style statements are prejudicial but may be remedied, not automatically struck out.
Labour procedure; witness statements as evidence; Order 18 Rule 5A CPR applicable where Industrial Court rules are silent; concurrent filing preserves credibility; late filings and rebuttals prejudicial and ethically impermissible; remedial discretion to allow rebuttal rather than striking out.
|
5 October 2023 |
|
Applicant’s employment dispute barred by the respondent’s Cooperation Agreement‑based immunity; no waiver shown, application dismissed.
International organizations — Privileges and immunities — Cooperation Agreement conferring UN‑specialized‑agency immunities — Diplomatic Privileges Act and Regulations — Official acts and inviolability of premises, archives and documents — Waiver of immunity required to permit jurisdiction.
|
2 October 2023 |
| September 2023 |
|
|
Industrial Court may hear High Court-referred judicial review challenging unlawful interdiction and grant reinstatement and arrears.
* Industrial Court jurisdiction – section 8 LADASA – jurisdiction over matters referred by other courts; * Judicial review – amenability where employment and disciplinary action involve public law and statutory bodies; * Public Service interdiction – Regulation 38 PSC Regulations – statutory timeframes and right to appeal; * Reinstatement/mandamus – discretionary remedy related to employment law (Employment Act s.71) and judicial review prerogative orders; * Salary entitlements during interdiction – entitlement to at least half salary and restoration upon conclusion of proceedings; * Evidence/verification – role of UNEB verification and police complaints in disciplinary process.
|
27 September 2023 |
|
Employee unlawfully dismissed for unproven misconduct and denied fair disciplinary process; awarded compensation, interest and half costs.
* Employment law – unfair dismissal – substantive and procedural fairness under sections 58, 66 and 68 Employment Act 2006.* Employer definition – look to the economic enterprise and control, not merely corporate form; capacity to be sued despite business/contractual layers.* Evidence – unsigned minutes insufficient to prove a disciplinary hearing; employer must prove misconduct.* Remedies – notice pay, salary arrears, public holiday pay, general damages, interest and costs; severance and repatriation denied.
|
27 September 2023 |
|
|
6 September 2023 |
|
|
5 September 2023 |
|
Industrial Court has referral jurisdiction over High Court-referred labour disputes; employment claims governed by a six-year limitation.
* Labour law – Industrial Court jurisdiction – referral and appellate jurisdiction under LADASA; may hear matters referred by the High Court or other law. * Procedural law – referral by Labour Officer is not the exclusive route to the Industrial Court; referral by other courts valid. * Limitation – Limitation Act (six years) applies to employment disputes; claims within six years are not time-barred. * Preliminary objections – must raise pure points of law; factual disputes are for trial.
|
1 September 2023 |
| August 2023 |
|
|
Leave to appeal granted because a final determination on jurisdiction is required before further proceedings.
Industrial Court jurisdiction; leave to appeal; oral applications for leave competent; threshold of real prospect of success; jurisdictional questions may warrant leave to appeal before further proceedings.
|
31 August 2023 |
|
Court allowed amendment to add unlawful/illegal termination declarations, holding mediation disclosures confidential and awarding costs to the respondent.
Industrial/Employment law – amendment of pleadings – Order 6 Rule 19 CPR – whether amendment introduces new cause of action – mediation confidentiality under Judicature (Mediation) Rules 2013 – prejudice, delay and costs.
|
30 August 2023 |
|
|
29 August 2023 |
|
Leave to appeal on questions of fact granted where applicant showed the Labour Officer’s evaluation of evidence and omitted remedies warranted appellate review.
* Employment law – leave to appeal on questions of fact under Section 94(2) Employment Act – threshold: factual issues must have formed part of the Labour Officer’s decision and reasons given for re-arguing them on appeal.
* Civil procedure – effect of failure to file an affidavit in reply – applicant’s evidence stands unchallenged though respondent may address points of law; new evidence from the Bar not admitted on application for leave.
* Labour arbitration – evaluation of evidence and omission to pronounce on remedies – may constitute questions of fact or mixed law and fact warranting leave to appeal.
|
29 August 2023 |
|
Applicant granted leave to appeal on factual/mixed issues where the Labour Officer allegedly failed to evaluate evidence and pronounce on reliefs.
* Employment law – leave to appeal to Industrial Court – section 94(2) Employment Act – appeal on questions of fact or mixed law and fact.
* Civil procedure – failure to file affidavit in reply – effect of unchallenged evidence and limitation to points of law.
* Evidence – evaluation of evidence by Labour Officer – omission to pronounce on reliefs as ground for appeal.
* Appeals – admission of additional/new evidence on appeal – conditions under Order 43 Rule 22 CPR.
|
29 August 2023 |
|
The claimant’s mutual termination upheld; awarded severance and terminal benefits but denied other damages.
Employment law – section 71 Employment Act – Labour Officer’s discretion to entertain complaints out of time; Mutual termination and effect of a signed termination letter; Jurisdiction of employer during notice period and disciplinary powers; Admission of misconduct and effect on need for disciplinary proceedings; Entitlement to severance under employer’s Human Resources Manual – calculation of severance; Requirement for strict proof of special damages.
|
23 August 2023 |
|
Redundancy termination without following CBA and statutory procedure was unlawful; claimant awarded severance, notice pay, damages and costs.
* Employment law – collective bargaining – incorporation of Collective Bargaining Agreement into individual contract – redundancy procedure and entitlements under CBA and Employment Act. * Termination – redundancy – requirement to give notice to employee/union and notify Labour Commissioner – failure to comply renders termination unlawful. * Remedies – pay in lieu of notice, severance (one month per completed year), repatriation allowance, general damages, certificate of service, costs.
|
23 August 2023 |
|
Employer’s failure to reinstate or communicate after employee’s acquittal amounted to constructive dismissal; remedies awarded.
* Employment law – Constructive dismissal – Employer’s unreasonable conduct by failing to reinstate or communicate after employee’s acquittal – breach of mutual trust and confidence.
* Employment law – Criminal proceedings and employment – employer may await criminal process but must act after acquittal; election to await may lead to constructive dismissal if no steps taken.
* Remedies – Severance, pay in lieu, basic compensatory pay, salary arrears for period of prosecution, general damages; additional compensation under s.78(2)–(3) is within Labour Officer’s discretion.
* Interest – monetary awards to carry interest at 19% p.a.; no order as to costs.
|
21 August 2023 |
|
Court finds termination unlawful and unfair; awards additional severance and general damages, denies discrimination and punitive claims.
Industrial and employment law – Termination of employment – Mutual separation requires free and final consent; lack of consent converts purported mutual termination into unfair dismissal; employer must give notice or follow disciplinary hearing procedures under the Employment Act; acceptance of terminal payments does not necessarily estop employee where acceptance was conditional; claims for future earnings are speculative and generally denied; damages for unfair dismissal include severance and general damages, interest may be awarded; discrimination claims must be proved on the balance of probabilities.
|
18 August 2023 |
|
An employee’s admitted unauthorised transfer of employer airtime justified summary dismissal; formal hearing not required upon admission.
Labour law – summary dismissal – unauthorised transfer of employer airtime – employee admission dispenses with need for formal disciplinary hearing – breach of duty of fidelity justifying summary dismissal under Employment Act s69(3).
|
18 August 2023 |
|
A claimant's admission to prohibited conduct justified lawful summary dismissal; the unfair dismissal claim was dismissed.
* Employment law – Summary dismissal – Misconduct by carrying unauthorized passenger in employer’s vehicle – Admission of misconduct; * Procedural fairness – Right to be heard (Section 66 Employment Act) – Admission may render formal hearing redundant; * Summary dismissal justified where conduct constitutes fundamental breach (Section 69 Employment Act); * Evidential effect of criminal exoneration – does not negate employment misconduct.
|
18 August 2023 |
|
|
16 August 2023 |
|
Claimant's dismissal substantively justified but procedurally unfair, resulting in compensation, severance and damages.
Labour law – unfair dismissal; procedural fairness – contents of disciplinary notice, right to be accompanied, and provision of investigation/audit report; substantive fairness – employer's genuine belief and disciplinary findings; remedies – compensation, severance, notice pay, general damages, repatriation and interest.
|
16 August 2023 |
|
Court authorised substituted service by publication where respondents were evasive and counsel refused to accept service.
Substituted service – Order 5 Rule 18 CPR – requirement that ordinary service be impossible – process server’s affidavit – evasive respondents – Advocates (Professional Conduct) Regulations (notice to withdraw) – inherent powers of the court – substituted service by publication – ex parte proceedings – costs.
|
16 August 2023 |
|
Applicant granted leave to amend claim to include recovered monies; Industrial Court may adjudicate related employment monetary disputes.
* Civil procedure – Amendment of pleadings – Leave to amend to enable determination of real controversy – Principles from Okello Wilbert v Obel Ronald.
* Labour law – Industrial Court jurisdiction – Power to adjudicate employment-related monetary claims arising from a labour dispute.
* Limitation – Defence remains available and may be determined at trial; does not automatically bar amendment.
* Amendment – Allegations of mala fides and prejudice must be established; absence of such findings supports granting leave.
|
16 August 2023 |
|
Summary dismissal for alleged restructuring was unlawful; claimant awarded terminal pay, severance, general and aggravated damages, interest.
Employment law – unfair and unlawful dismissal – restructuring/merger defence – employer must prove genuine reason, notify Commissioner and affected employees, and afford opportunity to be heard; failure renders termination substantively and procedurally unlawful. Terminal benefits – employer must prove lawful offsets for advances; absence of proof entitles employee to payment. Commission and allowance claims – claimant must prove completed sales and entitlement; vague or unallocated sales records fail. Remedies – payment in lieu of notice, severance, general and aggravated damages, and interest.
|
7 August 2023 |