|
Citation
|
Judgment date
|
| August 2018 |
|
|
Whether aggravated defilement was proved beyond reasonable doubt amid inconsistent medical and witness evidence.
Criminal law – Aggravated defilement – elements: unlawful sexual act, victim under 14, identity of offender, HIV infection
Evidence – child complainant’s testimony requires corroboration; medical evidence as corroboration
Evidence – inconsistencies, failure to produce physical exhibits and unexplained delays can raise reasonable doubt. Burden of proof – prosecution must prove all ingredients beyond reasonable doubt
|
29 August 2018 |
|
Trial court erred by failing to follow plea-bargain rules and mis-sentencing an unrepresented appellant.
Criminal procedure – Plea bargaining (Judicature (Plea Bargain) Rules 2016) – initiation and timing; court’s duty to facilitate negotiations and advise unrepresented accused; sentencing discretion; requirement of proof before labelling an accused a habitual offender; credit for remand and victim compensation.
|
24 August 2018 |
|
Court balanced sentencing guidelines, belated guilty‑plea discounts and juvenile rehabilitation in aggravated defilement sentences and remand set‑off.
Criminal law – Aggravated defilement of a child – sentencing principles; Sentencing Guidelines – death and life imprisonment reserved for most extreme cases; Guilty plea discounts – belated pleas attract smaller reduction; Children Act – juvenile sentencing, detention as last resort and disposition orders; Remand – statutory requirement to set off time spent on remand.
|
24 August 2018 |
|
Criminal law
|
24 August 2018 |
|
|
23 August 2018 |
|
|
22 August 2018 |
|
Circumstantial and identification evidence were insufficient to establish a prima facie case of murder against the accused.
Criminal law – Trial on Indictments Act s.73 – prima facie case; sufficiency of prosecution evidence to require accused to answer
Murder – elements: death, unlawful act, malice aforethought, identification of perpetrator. Circumstantial and identification evidence – reliability and sufficiency to ground conviction. Forensic/post‑mortem evidence – cause of death and inference of homicide
|
20 August 2018 |
|
Court accepted guilty plea to murder, declined death sentence, and imposed 14 years 5 months after remand deduction.
Criminal law – Murder – Plea bargain accepted after court satisfaction of voluntary guilty plea – Sentencing guidelines for capital offences – Mitigating and aggravating factors – Remand time set off from sentence.
|
20 August 2018 |
|
Child-to-child sex – HIV-positive juvenile – guilty plea – remand period – sentencing under the Children Act – rehabilitation – caution and discharge
|
20 August 2018 |
|
High Court may validate a magistrate's irregular venue for capital offences where transfer is justified by the interests of justice.
Criminal procedure — territorial jurisdiction v. venue — magistrates' limited local jurisdiction; High Court's nationwide jurisdiction; committal/ancillary jurisdiction in capital offences; improper venue as procedural irregularity curable by ratification/validation under s.41/Magistrates Courts Act; transfer of venue guided by interests of justice, fair trial and security considerations.
|
20 August 2018 |
|
Conviction quashed for unsafe evidence and improper burden-shifting; dispute was essentially civil, not criminal.
Criminal law – Obtaining money by false pretences – Elements: receipt of money and dishonest intent must be proved beyond reasonable doubt. Burden of proof – Remains on the prosecution; trial court must not shift burden to accused. False pretences – A statement of future intention is generally not a false pretence. Civil v criminal – Promise to perform (contractual disputes) may be civil, not criminal
Magistrates Courts Act s.197(1) – Compensation is recoverable by civil suit; execution order inappropriate
Evidence – Material contradictions in witness testimony render conviction unsafe
|
15 August 2018 |
|
Court relied on medical evidence to find juvenile criminally responsible, rejected a birth certificate, and imposed probation with strict conditions.
Criminal law – Juvenile offenders – Age determination: court may reject documentary evidence if unreliable and rely on medical evidence under Children Act s107(2). Criminal law – Aggravated defilement (Penal Code s129) – Death penalty barred for under-eighteens; Children Act limits juvenile detention to three years and makes detention a last resort
Sentencing – Children Act s94 – factors to balance mitigation and aggravation; credit for guilty plea and remand time
Disposition – Probation and binding over, conditions, and consequences for breach (re-commitment to custody)
|
13 August 2018 |
|
The accused convicted of manslaughter was released as time served after mitigation and remand credit reduced the sentence.
Criminal law – Manslaughter – Sentence: appropriate starting points and reduction for mitigation and remand credit; use of weapon and fatal external haemorrhage as aggravating factor. Sentencing law – Application of Sentencing Guidelines and precedents; principle of proportionality and parsimony
Procedural – Credit for time spent on remand under Article 23(8) and Sentencing Guidelines
|
10 August 2018 |
|
Court accepted guilty pleas for double murder by poisoning and sentenced the accused to concurrent nine years four months, with remand credited.
Criminal law – Plea bargaining – Court’s acceptance of a voluntary, informed guilty plea where there is a factual basis
Murder – poisoning – organophosphate poisoning causing death of two children; multiple victims and vulnerability as aggravating factors
Sentencing – application of Sentencing Guidelines and appellate precedents; remand credit under Article 23(8) and Regulation 15(2) deducted from agreed sentence
Sentence – concurrent imprisonment resulting from plea agreement and remand set-off
|
10 August 2018 |
|
Court balanced rehabilitation and public protection in sentencing a juvenile for aggravated defilement, imposing probation with strict conditions.
Criminal law – Juvenile sentencing – Aggravated defilement – Children Act prohibits death penalty for under‑18s and limits detention to three years; detention as last resort – Guilty plea credit and remand set‑off – Probation and protective conditions.
|
10 August 2018 |
|
Juvenile under 18 convicted of aggravated defilement; court applied Children Act: remand credit, guilty-plea discount, probation with non-contact and custody conditions.
Children — Sentencing — Death penalty inapplicable to offenders under 18 — alternative dispositions under Children Act
Children — Detention as last resort — factors to consider under s.94 (gravity, rehabilitation prospects, remand credit)
Sentencing — Plea of guilty — permissible mitigation and necessity to state its effect
Probation — supervision conditions, binding over, residence and non-contact orders; breach consequences
|
10 August 2018 |
|
Accused convicted on guilty plea of manslaughter; sentenced after mitigation and remand credit to the custodial term stated.
Criminal law – Manslaughter – plea of guilty – acceptance of plea and facts establishing manslaughter under ss.187, 190 Penal Code Act Sentencing – application of Third Schedule Sentencing Guidelines – starting point and adjustment for mitigating and aggravating factors Mitigation – intoxication, provocation, first offender, ill health, remorse, family responsibilities Remand credit – deduction of time spent on remand pursuant to Article 23(8) and sentencing regulations Use of blunt instrument – relevance to severity but not automatically mandating life imprisonment
|
8 August 2018 |
|
Court accepted plea bargain for aggravated defilement, imposed 4 years 2 months imprisonment after ten months remand credit.
Criminal law – Aggravated defilement (s.129(3) & 4(b) Penal Code) – plea bargaining – validity and factual basis of guilty plea; sentencing – aggravating factor: accused HIV positive; mitigating factors: age (18), first offender, dependants, guilty plea; remand credit under sentencing guidelines.
|
8 August 2018 |
|
Juvenile convicted of aggravated defilement given probation and binding‑over; detention avoided after remand credit and mitigation.
Juvenile sentencing — aggravated defilement — Children Act limits (no death sentence for under‑18s; maximum three years' detention) — detention as last resort — credit for guilty plea and remand time — probation and binding‑over orders — protective conditions for victims.
|
8 August 2018 |
|
The respondent convicted of aggravated robbery received custodial sentences; the juvenile received probation and binding‑over, with remand credited.
Criminal law – Aggravated robbery with deadly weapons – Sentencing under Sentencing Guidelines – application of mitigating factors including guilty plea, youth and first offender status; deduction of remand time; Children Act — juvenile sentencing as last resort, probation and binding‑over; mandatory compensation under Penal Code s.286(4).
|
8 August 2018 |
|
Juvenile convicted of aggravated defilement; detention limited by Children Act, guilty plea and remand time resulted in release as time served.
Criminal law – Children Act – sentencing of juveniles – death sentence precluded for under-18; maximum detention three years – detention as last resort and rehabilitation primary
Sentencing – guilty plea and time on remand as mitigating factors and set-off under section 94(3). Sexual offences – aggravated defilement: gravity may justify detention despite youth
|
7 August 2018 |
|
A juvenile convicted of aggravated defilement was released as time served after credit for guilty plea, mitigation and remand time.
Criminal law – Aggravated defilement – juvenile offender – statutory prohibition on death sentence and maximum three years’ detention under the Children Act
Sentencing – juveniles – detention as last resort; factors for and against custodial disposition (gravity, victim vulnerability, offender's remorse, conduct on remand, prospects for rehabilitation). Sentencing credit – guilty plea and pre‑trial remand to be taken into account
Children Act – section 94(1)(g) and section 104(A)(1) implications
|
7 August 2018 |
|
Juvenile convicted of aggravated defilement: death prohibited by Children Act; probation with remand credit ordered.
Criminal law – Aggravated defilement – juvenile offender under 18 – Children Act limits on death penalty and detention; detention as last resort
Sentencing – considerations for juveniles: gravity, culpability, rehabilitation prospects, guilty plea and remand credit
Disposition – substitution of probation and binding over where short detention is not useful
|
7 August 2018 |
|
Juvenile given benefit of doubt on age and sentenced to nine months' detention for aggravated defilement.
Criminal law – Aggravated defilement; Children Act – age determination and benefit of doubt; juveniles – prohibition of death penalty and maximum detention; sentencing – mitigation for guilty plea and remand credit; rehabilitation vs incapacitation.
|
7 August 2018 |
|
Juvenile convicted of aggravated defilement sentenced to six months' probation and bound over after remand set‑off.
Children — Age determination under the Children Act — Juvenile sentencing for aggravated defilement — Death sentence prohibited for offenders under 18 — Statutory maximum three years' detention — Detention as last resort — Credit for guilty plea and remand set‑off — Probation and binding over as alternatives to custody.
|
7 August 2018 |
|
Conviction for aggravated defilement where medical evidence and consistent victim testimony proved all statutory elements beyond reasonable doubt.
Criminal law – Aggravated defilement – elements: unlawful sexual intercourse, victim under 14, identity of perpetrator, authority over victim – proof beyond reasonable doubt; corroboration by medical evidence and witness statements; defence claim of fabrication due to organisational dispute rejected.
|
6 August 2018 |
|
Juvenile convicted of aggravated defilement found under 18; remand time set off and released under supervised family care.
Juvenile justice – age determination under section 107(2) Children Act – court may consider appearance and any evidence despite conflicting identity documents; Children Act – prohibition of death sentence for under‑18s (s.104A(1)) and maximum detention for such offences (s.94(1)(g)); Sentencing – guilty plea and mitigation under sentencing guidelines (reg.21(k)) may reduce custody; Remand – time on remand to be set off against detention (s.94(3)); Conditional release – supervision by probation officer and family placement with breach consequence.
|
6 August 2018 |
|
Juvenile convicted of aggravated defilement: death prohibited; detention capped and time served set off, resulting in release.
Children — Sentencing — Aggravated defilement by a juvenile — Death sentence prohibited for under‑18s; alternative maximum detention three years under the Children Act — Detention as last resort — Guilty plea and remand time as mitigating factors — Time served set off.
|
6 August 2018 |
|
Juvenile convicted of aggravated defilement sentenced under Children Act: remand credit, guilty-plea mitigation and probation with conditional custody.
Children Act – sentencing of juveniles – death penalty inapplicable where offender was under 18; statutory maximum detention three years and detention as last resort; probation as alternative. Criminal law – aggravated defilement – gravity of repeated sexual intercourse with a nine-year-old
Sentencing – mitigation for guilty plea, credit for remand time, and consideration of rehabilitation and public protection
|
6 August 2018 |
|
Juvenile under eighteen convicted of aggravated defilement; death excluded, remand time set off and released as time served.
Criminal law – Juvenile sentencing – Aggravated defilement – Death penalty precluded for offenders under eighteen; Children Act provides maximum three years’ detention – Detention as last resort – Guilty plea mitigation – Remand time set‑off under s.94(3).
|
6 August 2018 |
|
Juvenile convicted of aggravated defilement received a one‑year disposition set off by time served, resulting in release.
Children Act – Sentencing of juveniles – Death penalty excluded for persons under 18; maximum detention three years – Detention as last resort. Aggravated defilement – gravity, trickery and young victim as aggravating factors
Sentencing – credit for guilty plea and mitigation; set off of remand time under s.94(3). Rehabilitation and best interests of the child in disposition decisions
|
6 August 2018 |
|
Juvenile convicted of aggravated defilement cannot receive death; detention capped and reduced to seven months after mitigations.
Criminal law – Aggravated defilement – juvenile offender; Children Act – death penalty prohibited for under 18s; maximum juvenile detention three years
Sentencing – children’s diminished culpability; detention as last resort; factors for juvenile sentencing
Mitigation – guilty plea discount; first offender and remorse
Procedure – remand time to be set off under section 94(3)
|
6 August 2018 |