|
Citation
|
Judgment date
|
| July 1996 |
|
|
Medical proof of penetration without corroboration of a child’s unsworn identification is insufficient to convict for defilement.
Criminal law – Defilement – Elements: victim’s age, penetration, identity of perpetrator. Evidence – Child witness unsworn testimony requires corroboration under the Oath Act. Medical evidence – Hymenal rupture establishes penetration but does not alone corroborate identification of the assailant. Burden of proof – Prosecution must prove every essential element beyond reasonable doubt.
|
29 July 1996 |
|
Medical proof of penetration established defilement, but lack of corroboration for a child’s unsworn identification led to acquittal.
Criminal law – Defilement – Elements: age, penetration, identity – Medical evidence can prove penetration – Child’s unsworn testimony requires corroboration (Oath Act) – Corroboration absence defeats conviction – Warning authorities in rape cases do not substitute for statutory corroboration in defilement cases.
|
29 July 1996 |
|
Accused convicted of kidnapping with intent to murder; s.235(2) presumption applied and compulsion defence failed, sentenced to four years.
Criminal law – Kidnapping with intent to murder – Elements and burden of proof; statutory presumption under s.235(2) where victim not seen for six months; defence of compulsion (s.16) requires threat of instant death or grievous bodily harm; assessment of witness inconsistencies and sentencing discretion for first offenders.
|
29 July 1996 |
|
Plea to manslaughter accepted; sentencing balanced provocation and two years' pre-trial custody as mitigation.
Criminal law – Plea acceptance – Manslaughter as a minor and cognate offence to murder; Sentencing principles – fitting the offence and the offender; provocation and pre-trial custody as mitigating factors; absence of post-mortem noted.
|
17 July 1996 |
|
|
17 July 1996 |
|
Civil Procedure
|
16 July 1996 |
|
|
16 July 1996 |
|
Boiling-water assault causing death constitutes aggravated manslaughter; court imposed six-year term with two years' credit.
Criminal law – Manslaughter (s.182 Penal Code) – Sentence – Pouring boiling water as brutal act; foreseeability of fatal consequences – Delayed death does not negate seriousness of injury – Mitigating factors: first offender, dependants, custody credit.
|
16 July 1996 |
|
A first-time offender was sentenced to six years for brutally murdering his wife, with remand time and intoxication considered.
Criminal law – Manslaughter – Plea of guilty to a lesser offence accepted; sentencing – consideration of remand time, first offender status, intoxication, and brutality as aggravating factor; spousal killing condemned.
|
16 July 1996 |
|
|
16 July 1996 |
|
|
16 July 1996 |
|
Accused pleaded to manslaughter; despite no postmortem, court found causation and sentenced her to four years imprisonment.
Criminal law – Manslaughter – Plea of guilty to lesser offence accepted – No postmortem but causation found – Sentencing considerations: gravity of wounds, proximity to murder, offender’s age.
|
16 July 1996 |
|
Criminal law
|
5 July 1996 |
|
Improper discharge for abduction under reconciliation; court required Section 125 MCA application for case disposition.
Criminal procedure – discharge of accused – reconciliation under Section 156 MCA inapplicable for abduction charges – proper use of Section 125 MCA.
|
1 July 1996 |
|
Case dismissal reversed due to failure to notify complainant, impacting child's welfare.
Criminal Law – Neglect to provide for a child – Dismissal for non-appearance of prosecutor – Requirement for notifying complainant of hearing.
|
1 July 1996 |
|
Erroneous dismissal under s.117 MCA rectified; trial to continue under s.125 and 126 for fair judgment.
Criminal procedure – appeal and revision – improper dismissal under s. 117 Magistrates Courts Act – correct application of s. 125 and 126.
|
1 July 1996 |
|
Sentence of corporal punishment deemed illegal for a 16-year-old offender under section 191(3) of MCA 1970.
Criminal Law – Theft – Sentencing – Legality of corporal punishment for offenders aged 16 – Section 191(3) MCA 1970
|
1 July 1996 |